Tuesday, December 16, 2008

A Crucial Question: Revisited







A note from Radarsite: I am reposting this earlier Radarsite article in response to Stop the ACLU's John Ray's excellent and thought-provoking December 14 article "Assumptions in Moral debate". http://www.stoptheaclu.com/archives/2008/12/14/assumptions-in-moral-debate/
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------




In response to a recent Radarsite article our good friend and fellow blogger Findalis began her comments with this important but unfortunately still controversial statement:

Findalis said...
I am reminded that this war is a war
between the forces of Good against the forces of Evil.

To properly defend ourselves against this ruthless onslaught of the Bloody Religion of Peace we must first and foremost accept the existence of Evil. For some of our delusional friends on the left this seems to be a concept that is totally foreign to them. All wars, they hasten to explain, are merely the selfish actions of self-interested nation-states competing for world hegemony. All the participants have equally meritorious claims. In these great global conflicts there is no such thing as right or wrong, just differing perspectives.

If this view of our world is correct then Islam has as much moral standing as Christianity or Judaism, and is just as valid a form of society as a democracy.

How can we prosecute the GWOT and not believe in the existence of Evil?
In response to this question I am reposting a previously published article, which is I believe worth revisiting. In my opinion, there can be no better experts to answer this weighty question. - rg

----------------------------------------------------------------------




A Crucial Question: Two Important Answers




Sir John Keegan:
"The world's preeminent military historian."











Professor Gerhard Weinberg:
"One of the world's foremost scholars on
Hitler and Nazi Germany."














Recently Radarsite had occasion to pose the following question to both Sir John Keegan and Prof. Gerhard Weinberg:
"Considering the number of revisionist histories which have been published in these past few decades, attempting to depict the Second World War as merely a morally-neutral conflict between nation-states over competing self-interests, do you still believe that that war was indeed a battle between Good and Evil?"

Both men answered with an unequivocal, Yes. Despite all of the intervening arguments to the contrary, both of these acknowledged experts still viewed WWII as a battle between the forces of Good and the forces of Evil -- although, Prof. Weinberg added that the forces of Good had had to make temporary common cause with another force of Evil (the Soviet Union) in order to achieve its ultimate victory.

Why is this an important question today?

In our present PC society, where almost every moral stance has been eroded and weakened by those currently-popular concepts of moral equivalency, it is crucial for this beleaguered country of ours to accept the fact that Evil does exist. And, to believe that that is what we are currently fighting against; and that, as flawed as we may be, we are indeed the forces of Good.

http://radarsite.blogspot.com/2008/02/crucial-question-two-important-answers.html

3 comments:

  1. Again I will state that the war between Islam and the West is a war between Good and Evil.

    For one to accept this one first must read both the Koran and the Bible. Seeing the differences between the 3 major religions of the Western world, one discovers that Islam is based on War, Death and Hatred. There are no 10 Commandments in Islam, there is no Love thy Neighbor in Islam. There is only war and hatred in Islam.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I believe in the battles between good and evil. Any government believing that people have no right to free will is evil.

    ReplyDelete
  3. If evil can be denied then what is there to prevent evil acts from spreading?

    Even a young child has a balance of good or evil intent it is just the fine tuning through learning that needs to be adjusted.

    Good post Roger

    ReplyDelete